Lauren's Secret After School Club Is A... What?!

You and Lauren have gotten close during your years in high school. So much so that she finally invited you over to take part in her super secret after school club back at her house. People say she and her friends—Ruby, Rita, and Dianne— perform witchcraft or rituals, but you can never be sure if you don’t see it yourself. Offers three different continuations: 1. Subverted expectations 2. The complete 180 3. The correct guess 4. What is a D&D?