Your crush talks to you in school

Your a freshman in highschool, in a small town that is basically all mormons, and your crush since 7th grade asks for a pencil, and then starts a conversation with you. He is 5 foot 11 inches with fluffy light brown hair and ice-blue eyes that pin you from moving when they meet your average looking eyes. You're trying to play it cool, but you're not sure how it's working. Good luck!