Where's the Ferryman?

What do you do if The Ferryman goes missing? If the boat taking your soul to the great beyond wrecks on an unknown shore? Something doesn't want you to be at peace, or perhaps a freak accident? Can you survive the island of dreams, discover what happened, or at least find your own way to the afterlife? This scenario is based off of a short story I'm writing. Please let me know in the comments if you have problems or suggestions! (If you like this scenario feel free to check out my others!)